Modern plots.
Modern plots.
Sobering up process.
Position in our sobering establishments is not better, than in
Other establishments supervised by our law-enforcement system,
- For example, in investigatory insulators, where - a fact of common knowledge
- People mrut, as flies.
1.
And tell, you, personally you, got to a sobering-up station, fairly
Having drunk? Well though once?
Did not get. And if there was such misfortune, feel ashamed
To admit.
And to be ashamed and it is not necessary.
First, to whom does not happen. Secondly, remember: everyone
Sobering-up station at us MEDICAL. And according to the order of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the USSR from 30
May, 1985 (it is impossible to cancel such good order even
Owing to disintegration of the USSR, and it is not excellent) in the given establishment about
You will be obliged to care how not any wife will take care.
The native spouse will not restrain to blame and grumble begins, different
Insulting words to speak supposedly nazjuzilsja, such-sjakoj, useless, and
Other muzhiks all in the house, all in the house, instead of in a tavern.
In a sobering-up station (MEDICAL - cut to itself on a nose!) you
Should accept such what you are, your person, what it
Rumpled was at present, to establish, you
Will examine, will help to undress and be washed (if need
The such is available), will bring to a pure bed, and then specially
The people put for this purpose should protect yours in every possible way
Dream and health.
In the order which we mentioned, and it is told: "the Person on duty on
To medical sobering-up station... Carries out personally and with the help
The medical assistant and militiamen the control over behaviour and a status
Health of the persons who are on sobering ". And to the militiaman,
Which carries out "supervision over the persons placed on
Sobering ", in duties is made" constant supervision for
Behaviour and status of the persons who are in chambers ", acceptance of measures
"To the prevention of cases of death, fulfilment of suicides or
Causings of physical injuries ", that is not out of place, for that only not
vzbredaet in a head to the drunk person.
But I will continue.
The medical worker who is by all means being at a sobering-up station
(Once again I remind, that became an unconditioned reflex, -
MEDICAL), not only "watches maintenance of the ought
Sanitary status of the medical sobering-up station established
Temperature mode of air and water ", not only fills up a drugstore
Establishments medicines, and first-aid sets of crews means of the first
The help, not only trains workers medvytrezvitelja "in ability
To render this very first help to the persons who have been found out in streets and
In other public places in helpless or dangerous to a life
Status "also carries out other duties provided
The application number two to the order mentioned above on the Ministry of Internal Affairs, but - and
This most important thing - "checks a state of health of persons,
Being on sobering ", and" in cases of revealing of deterioration
Health at sobered citizens "itself personally" provides
Rendering of timely medical aid ".
For, article 63, "purpose is spoken in the order on the Ministry of Internal Affairs,
medvytrezvitelja it is called to sobering of citizens, instead of their place
б destructions ".
2.
Citizen S.P.Ivanov has been delivered on May, 26th, 1994 in
Novokuznetsk medvytrezvitel number four in "average degree
Intoxications ".
Before this accident it was the perfect family man,
Kind companion and the excellent worker - the chief of department in
"Zapsibremonte". It had two diplomas about higher education. It
There was a lucid mind. It knew as the tireless rationalizer and
The inventor with huge engineering experience. Two with superfluous year
Ivanov has worked in India on reconstruction of the metallurgical
Combine in Bhilai - the characteristic more than sufficient on
To Soviet times.
Gold, mild character. According to character
Hobby - tourism, the pedestrian and water. Normal health - with
Backpack across Sayan mountains and Celestial Teeths it is strong not nabrodish,
Being hiljakom.
I will add here happy marriage - three children, the wife is pregnant
The fourth.
So, in the evening on May, 26th, 1994 it was, I will repeat once again, quite
It is healthy, strong enough and only in "average degree
Intoxications "which has established at it medical assistant N.P.Sudochakova. And
In the morning on May, 27th the chief of the Department of Internal Affairs of administration of Novokuznetsk
N.F.Medjantsev has confirmed the conclusion "upon a lethal outcome
Gr th Ivanov indoors medvytrezvitelja number 4
Of Novokuznetsk ".
It appears, at 21 o'clock on May, 26th in chamber number two "has occurred
The conflict between patients "." The Militiamen conducting supervision for
Chambers, Derk N.P. and Proshkin J.V., have disunited clashing "-
Have translated one of participants of the conflict in other chamber. Another
Remained. It was somebody M.V.Gonchar (at its establishment
Persons it has appeared ostensibly apparatchikom the same shop of Zapsib, where
S.P.Ivanov, it agree to "Conclusion" data, was the senior master,
That incorrectly also testifies, that the establishment of persons was
It is spent by workers medvytrezvitelja somehow).
"Patient" A.I.Kuvshinov testifies, that M.V.Gonchar
"Stuck to patients", tried to carp to most Kuvshinovu, and
When "Ivanov has told, that the Potter has calmed down and has laid down to have a rest","at
Them has arisen like quarrel, and at this time the Potter has struck a series
Blows, at first fists, then a foot on a head, probably, knowing
Receptions of blows, blows were sharp, fast, all has occurred
Instantly ".
After Ivanov Gonchar it was switched on Kuvshinova. Well, here noise,
At last, has reached ears rabonikov a sobering-up station, and "Derk and proshkin
Have quickly entered into chamber ". Then they" have quickly deduced the Potter from
Chambers ". And further" whereas the potter already translated from
Chambers in chamber to prevent its further violence ",
All have neutralised the fighter, having chained in "spetskreslo".
And here "patients in chamber have cried, that the medical is necessary
The help as to Ivanov it is bad ".
Further in "Conclusion" it is told, that "medical assistant Sudochakova
N.P. Has quickly entered into chamber, has examined Ivanov ". But to the medical assistant there
There was nothing to do already. There there was a job already to the pathologist,
Which has established, that "the death has come owing to bazalnogo
subarahnoidalnogo hemorrhages "(well, of course, if the karateka and
If a foot yes on a head).
To the chief of the Department of Internal Affairs N.F.Medjantsevu have informed, that "upon the corporal
Ivanovu S.P.'s damages concerning the citizen of the Potter of M. of Century
Criminal case ", and the dress on duty medvytrezvitelja is raised -
Senior lieutenant V.V.Timoshenko, the foreman P.N.Andrashuk, senior
Sergeant N.P.Derk, private soldier J.V.Proshkin and medical assistant N.P.Sudochakova
"The functional duties carried out according to
Requirements of the order number 106 Ministries of Internal Affairs of the USSR from 30.05.85 and
Infringements of its requirements have not admitted "and, means," fault of the person on duty
The dress... In a lethal outcome to gr th Ivanova S.P. is absent ".
From this follows, that it is necessary "to consider office investigation
Finished ", but with staff medvytrezvitelej all would be necessary
To conduct additional lessons, "having considered the given incident
With development of measures on prevention and suppression of the given situations ".
3.
Well, both to me, and to you it is absolutely clear, that the senior
The lieutenant, sergeants with gr th Ivanov's private soldiers most likely not
Beat. And especially the medical assistant. On the contrary, they "have quickly entered" and
"Have quickly deduced" the brawler of the Potter. Earlier they, probably, so
"Quickly" moved from chamber to chamber the future murderer, planting
Its that with one, with another, with which "patient" time from
Time entered "quarrel".
More shortly, militiamen from themselves have removed fault.
The further events developed thus. On August, 27th 1994
Year the senior inspector of Office of Public Prosecutor of Factory area
Novokuznetsk, the lawyer of 2nd class N.V.Semjakina, "having considered
Materials of criminal case upon Ivanov's murder, has established ",
That in a sobering-up station there was a quarrel between two drunk, "in a course
Which Potter, not having intention on causing of the heavy corporal
Damages... Two times has struck (a hand and has kicked with a foot) Ivanov on
To body. One of blows has had on a neck, has called bazalnoe
Hemorrhage, then Ivanov within several minutes
Has died ". The potter" has explained ", that has struck" once, probably,
Two also"did not assume, that there can be heavy consequences".
The senior inspector has referred to certain not named disease,
Transferred by Ivanov "at the moment of drawing to it of blow", after
That, the senior inspector believes, referring on
Forensic medical examination, there was "an inflammatory process in
Site of a brain and soft brain covers ".
That is, "the found out inflammatory process in a brain
Ivanov could be an immediate cause of death or it is strong
To affect an outcome ". Considering, that" any doubt is interpreted in
Advantage of the suspected person ", the senior inspector Factory
The lawyer of 2nd class N.V.Semjakina does Offices of Public Prosecutor of Novokuznetsk
The conclusion, that "takes place an unfortunate case-incident" that is, it is necessary
"Criminal case upon Ivanov's death which corpse is lifted
(Here such already there is a formulation! - the note
The author) in medvytrezvitele number of 4 of Novokuznetsk of 26.05.94,
To stop behind absence in actions of the Potter of structure
The crime provided by item 106 UK the Russian Federation, item 108
ch. 2 UK the Russian Federation ".
Have removed now fault and from the brawler of the Potter, having found at Ivanov certain
Quite mythical illness, which, as far as I know, in
The medicolegal investigation certificate it is not reflected (though other beating, not is reflected
Taken into consideration the inspector) but from which Ivanov could
To die and by itself.
Spouse S.P.Ivanov remains with four
Children on hands. One of them - the newborn. Right after sorts
It gets again to hospital - it had to protect the girl, on
Which in a court yard the dog has attacked. To inform, for example, to the Moscow
To relatives about happened it could only after sorokovin. And
To defend the rights of the late husband, and children it has begun the only
After some months.
Finally Ivanov has achieved repeated excitation
Criminal case concerning the Potter, an objective consequence and
Vessels. And the Potter nevertheless has been condemned. However, on rather
To "soft" article 106 of the Criminal code (murder on
Imprudence) and only by three years of imprisonment and that
With a delay of execution of a sentence.
And on December, 3rd, 1996 Factory court of Novokuznetsk the
With the decision has satisfied claim requirements Ivanovoj "about compensation
Harm occasionally uteri the supporter ".
The public prosecutor of Factory area V.I.Chelpanov, however, has protested
The decision. Not having anything against a court conclusion about guilt of the Potter and
About the decision on satisfaction of the claim occasionally uteri the supporter, it
Has considered, that the sum of single compensation of a damage (107 million
In a standard of price of 1996) a family, and also the monthly grant
To children (on 729 thousand in the same standards of price and to majority,
Since January, 1st, 1997) it is too great.
It is necessary to direct business on new judicial consideration.
4.
Now on a court yard the end of 1998. Courts, cassations,
Trials and retrials Natalia Nikolaevna Ivanov
Has gone through so much "nest bills it. I Will note advantage received by it
Higher education and intelligent education - Ivanov conducts
The business without lawyers.
Independently. However, money for lawyers at it all the same
No.
It is persevering. It in perplexity - the person was lost in
The official body called by the MEDICAL. She spends
Analogies: if the driver driving the car in any
To the state office, will break in a state of intoxication someone's another
The car the caused damage is paid popervu by office, and
Then it sues the driver.
Conducted by such bewilderment, Natalia Nikolaevna gets to the bottom to
Order maintenances on the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the USSR from May, 1985. Also interprets it in
The advantage.
In passing it reaches "Conclusion" on the office
To investigation of a case, event in medvytrezvitele. Also does
Conclusion that is solidary with the murderer the Potter before it and its children
The establishment - that is a sobering-up station (so should respond,
The Novokuznetsk Department of Internal Affairs above it), on
To which occasion I once again will remind - it the MEDICAL sobering-up station,
They cannot punish for drunkenness and in him categorically it is impossible
To cripple people or, the it is more, to kill.
About clientele it, start up also useless, workers should
To care. I will underline it once again and polemicheski I will point.
Medical sobering-up station not that place where can "be lifted
Corpse ". Here we, the citizens of Russia protected by the Constitution and
Laws, having touched, should arrive drunk, and to leave
The sober.
To leave, not having received even a cold, because temperature
Air in "chambers" and water temperature in a shower, where us
"Freshen", the physician, and God forbid, if is obliged to supervise
The temperature or water will appear below the put 20 degrees on
To Celsius.
The same severe constraints concern maintenances of patients. I
I will use now this word without inverted commas. As in the order on the Ministry of Internal Affairs -
The patient.
To the patient the pure bed, but it not all is put. And that
Attention. That silence and an order. The MEDICAL sobering-up station -
Institution for normal, well, a little overestimated the
Possibilities as regards alcohol of people, instead of a brothel and not the chamber
Imprisonment before trail.
Unfortunately, the glory about ours "trezvakah" goes the thin. Many,
Very many quite normal people have got the personal sad
Experience, having got there. After all this self-supporting establishment which takes
From sinners for services, as for spending the night in three-stars hotel.
Therefore just "decent" which in a status to pay
"Hotel", also take first of all.
I will hypocritically not hide the past - and it was possible to me
To visit similar establishment. Late at night in deserted street
I in rather "average degree of intoxication" was caught by the missing
Militian crew...
And summarising own, rather modest specific
Experience with the huge sad experience got by Natalia
Nikolaevnoj Ivanovoj, I come to conclusion - position in ours
Sobering establishments it is not better, than in other establishments,
Supervised by our law-enforcement system, - for example, in
Investigatory insulators, where - a fact of common knowledge - people mrut,
As flies. By the way, Novokuznetsk SIZO, where some years
To that was lost at once some person, it is sad has glorified "the southern
Capital of Kuzbas "all over the country and for its limits.
Knowing about destiny of claims of N.N.Ivanovoj to the Novokuznetsk Department of Internal Affairs,
I come and to other conclusion - guilty persists in the
Errors.
I will quote a line from N.N.Ivanovoj's letter in judicial board
On civil cases of the Kemerovo regional court (session
It is supposed boards shortly, and it will be
To consider the protest on the decision of federal court Factory
Area of of Novokuznetsk about damage compensation under the claim):
"The representative of the Department of Internal Affairs of administration Platova E.N. declared by me
The claim did not recognise, explaining it that in the given situation from
Materials of office investigation of fault of workers
medvytrezvitelja number 4 Factory areas of of Novokuznetsk are not present ".
With the representative of the Department of Internal Affairs the public prosecutor of Factory area is solidary also
V.I.Chelpanov. Moreover, he considers: "Orders of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, on
Which basis the court has passed the decision on guilt of workers
medvytrezvitelja, a liability of infringement of the norms specified in
Them, it is not provided ".
As to office investigation I will doubt after
N.N.Ivanovoj in its quality. Nonsense it, instead of office
Investigation. Workers medvytrezvitelja have not tamed
The potential murderer and, means, have not executed properly
The duties.
As to the bases by which the public prosecutor is guided
V.I.Chelpanov also they, believes N.N.Ivanova, are doubtful, for in
Russia the decree "About compensation of the damage caused operates
To the citizen illegal actions state and public
The organisations, and also officials at execution by them office
Duties "from May, 18th, 1981. And the given decree categorically
Orders to the state body to indemnify a loss in the full
Volume irrespective of fault of officials, as state body,
"It bears responsibility for actions (inactivity)
The official ".
The definitive decision of judicial instances in favour of Ivanovoj
Will create precedent according to which claims to militia can
To fall down, as peas from a bag. And not only to militia, and in
Principle to all useless state system, in any way
Wishing to carry out the first precept of the state - to do so, that
To citizens was safely and (see that has wanted!) comfortably.
Will achieve or not Natalia Nikolaevna Ivanov of the? Meanwhile
She has achieved an apology from the Department of Internal Affairs
Regional administrations. With lateness for four years. To it write:
"Dear Natalia Nikolaevna! Department of Internal Affairs AKO brings the sincere
Condolences concerning б destruction of your husband ".
Well, it is already a lot of.
Vasily popok.
<$>
//* an information Source: Kuzbas (Kemerovo), 1.12.98
//* Reg. Nom. - 1081200074.08-------------------------------------------
|
